Denis LedererCanadian Waterproofing Systems · Victoria BC ☎ 250-889-5620

Flat roof systems · An honest comparison

Torch-on vs TPO vs EPDM — an honest comparison for the BC coast.

I install torch-on and TPO, I’ve repaired plenty of EPDM, and I sell none of them — so this page can say what the manufacturers’ pages won’t. Here is how the three flat-roof systems actually compare in Victoria’s weather: cost, lifespan, strengths, and where each one fails.

The three systems

Torch-on (SBS)TPOEPDM
What it isTwo plies of rubber-modified bitumen, melted on with a torchSingle-ply white membrane, seams heat-weldedSingle-ply black rubber membrane, seams taped/glued
Typical life, BC coast20–30 years20–25 years25–30+ years
Cost (installed, 2026 guidance)About $8–$15/sq ftAbout $7–$12/sq ftAbout $8–$13/sq ft
Best forSmall, cut-up roofs; lots of penetrations; roofs people walk onLarge, simple commercial and residential flat roofsBig roofs needing flex; roofs under decks or ballast
Watch out forOpen-flame install (insurer questions, fire watch matters); heavySeam quality is everything; punctures from careless foot trafficSeams are the weak point; black surface absorbs summer heat

Torch-on (SBS modified bitumen)

The workhorse of BC flat roofing for decades. Two layers, torched down, with a granulated top surface that shrugs off foot traffic and dropped tools. It is the most forgiving system around complicated details — vents, skylights, chimneys — because the membrane is worked hot into corners. Downsides: it is heavy, the install uses open flame (some insurers dislike that, and the installer’s fire discipline is the whole safety story), and a cheap torch-on job with single-ply shortcuts is where the system gets its bad name.

TPO

The modern commercial standard. Wide white sheets, seams welded with hot air so the joint is stronger than the membrane, and a reflective surface that keeps top floors cooler. On a big, simple roof it is usually the best value per year of life. Downsides: it punctures more easily than torch-on, quality varies between manufacturers and membrane thicknesses, and everything depends on weld quality — a badly welded seam looks fine and leaks in year three. This is the system in my TPO installation videos, watched 71,950 times for Part 1 alone.

EPDM

Synthetic rubber, around since the 1960s, and the longest-lived of the three when it is left alone — 25 to 30-plus years is normal. It flexes with building movement and handles ponding better than the others. Downsides: the seams are taped, not welded, and they are where EPDM roofs eventually fail; the black surface cooks in summer sun; and fewer Island installers work with it daily, so repairs can be done badly with the wrong materials.

Overlay, coating, or tear-off?

Two more options you will be quoted: an overlay (new roof over the old) saves tear-off money but is only honest if the existing roof is dry and sound underneath — a core sample tells you. A roof coating can buy a few years on a roof whose seams and details are still good; on a failing roof it is paint on a problem. When the insulation is wet or the details are done, tear-off and a proper new system is the only fix that lasts. I’ll tell you which one your roof actually is — that’s the condition report conversation.

The short version: big and simple → TPO. Small and complicated → torch-on. Flex, ballast or maximum lifespan → EPDM. Bad drainage → fix the slope first, whatever membrane you choose. Still not sure? That’s literally what a roofing project manager is for.

Frequently asked questions

Torch-on vs TPO — which is better for a flat roof?

For most larger, simpler roofs on the BC coast, TPO wins: welded seams, a reflective white surface, and 20–25 years of life at a lower cost per square foot. For small, cut-up roofs with many penetrations, torch-on (SBS) is often the better tool — it is tougher underfoot and more forgiving around details, and lasts 20–30 years. The honest answer depends on your roof’s size, slope, details and how it gets used, which is why Denis gives the same comparison on a roof that he gives on this page.

How long does each flat roof system last?

On the BC coast, with correct installation: TPO lasts about 20–25 years, EPDM about 25–30 years or more, and torch-on (SBS modified bitumen) about 20–30 years. In every system the details — seams, flashings, drains — fail before the field of the roof does, so installer skill matters more than the membrane brand.

Is torch-on roofing safe? Why do some insurers dislike it?

Torch-on is applied with an open-flame torch, so the fire risk during installation is real and some insurers charge more or ask questions. A trained installer manages it with fire watch, proper substrate protection and no torch work near combustible details — Denis has torched for decades without incident. If your insurer objects, TPO or a cold-applied system removes the issue entirely.

Can you put a new flat roof over the old one?

Sometimes — a single existing roof in sound, dry condition can take an overlay, which saves tear-off cost. But if the insulation underneath is wet, an overlay traps the problem and the new roof fails early. Two existing layers, or any sign of soaked insulation, means tear-off. A core sample settles the question before you spend money either way.

What is the best flat roof system for the BC coast?

The one matched to your building. Our coast means months of wind-driven rain, moss-friendly shade and the odd snow load — drainage and details decide survival more than membrane choice. TPO suits big simple roofs, torch-on suits small complex ones, EPDM suits roofs that need to flex and last. Get the slope-to-drain right first; every system fails on a roof that holds water.

Request an assessment

Tell me the building, the roof size if you know it, and what’s on it now. I’ll tell you which system I’d put on it — and which I wouldn’t.

Prefer to talk? Call 250-889-5620 or email info@waterproofingsystems.ca.

☎ Call Denis — 250-889-5620